noble experiment

Noble Experiment

Updated 2 months ago

Popular drinks

What's the vibe?

See all 570

See all 1885

1885 photos

Review Highlights

“ Secret entrance, dimly lit, skull wall , great drinks, what else do you need to make a great cocktail bar? ” in 38 reviews

“ My boyfriend and I sat at the bar and got the Dealer 's Choice and each drink we got, we really enjoyed! ” in 171 reviews

“ They only take reservations exactly one week in advance so make sure to do this right away as they fill up quick. ” in 34 reviews

Show more review highlights

People also searched for

Speakeasy Lounge

Speakeasy Bars

Hidden Bars

Vibey Restaurants

Location & Hours

Suggest an edit

San Diego, CA 92101

7th Ave & California St

East Village

You Might Also Consider

Tabac Cafe & Hookah

in Hookah Bars

Little Frenchie

in French, Wine Bars

Amenities and More

Ask the community.

Ask a question

Do they take walk ins?

Yes we walked in but had to wait about 15-20 minutes. It will depend on the time etc

Are Fridays walk-ins only? We weren't able to find any Friday reservations all month.

Weekend reservations are typically made in advance, especially in summer but I've always been able to walk in. The wait time is usually 1 hour.

Recommended Reviews

• 1 star rating Not good
• 2 star rating Could’ve been better
• 3 star rating OK
• 4 star rating Good
• 5 star rating Great

Select your rating

Overall rating

Noble Experiment is a great gem that redefines the speakeasy experience. From the moment you step through the discreet entrance, you are transported to an intimate and enchanting world. The ambiance is absolutely stunning, with dim lighting and limited seating that adds to the sense of exclusivity. The decor is unforgettable, with walls covered in skulls and breathtaking Renaissance-style paintings on the ceiling that make you feel like you are sipping cocktails in a work of art. What truly sets Noble Experiment apart is the personalized touch from the bartenders. When I mentioned I wanted something fruity and sweet, they created the most incredible strawberry cucumber vodka cocktail for me. It was perfectly balanced, refreshing, and absolutely delicious. Every drink is tailored to your preferences, making each one feel special and unique. If you are looking for an intimate and unforgettable night out with impeccable service and cocktails that feel like they were made just for you, Noble Experiment is a must-visit. It is easily one of the best cocktail experiences I have ever had.

Skull wall inside

Ceiling inside

Following dinner nearby, a local friend of mine and I went there for drinks on a Thursday night. Neighborhood is a bar which is also connected to a speakeasy being Noble experiment. There were pretty busy altogether , and had large group of friends/corporate groups throughout the bar. While we were there we found out that there is speakeasy - the wait time to get a table there was long - their bartenders are also servers, and the seating area is much smaller. The host advised us to have drinks at Neighborhood while waiting for our tables. After waiting for about 30 minutes, we got a text letting us know our table was ready. The bar is unique as they do not have a menu - the bartender comes over at your table and asks about your favorite liquor, drinks, preferences between sour and sweet etc, and makes you a drink based the conversation. Once served, you can make adjustments for your next drinks or explore a different route. Check them out!

See all photos from Daniela N. for Noble Experiment

I visited this Nobel recently and was really impressed by Blythe's exceptional service. She went above and beyond to accommodate me from a long waitlist situation and was incredibly patient, even as I waited for my date who never arrived. Her kindness, professionalism, and willingness to help truly made my experience stand out. As someone who works in the industry, I can say Blythe's hospitality is top-notch I also have to give credit to Josh, the bartender, for providing stellar service. Despite my picky palate, he offered creative drink suggestions and carefully tailored each cocktail to my tastes. His enthusiasm, knowledge, and warm demeanor really enhanced my evening, making me feel right at home. Together, Blythe and Josh made my visit unforgettable after what I thought was gonna be sad night!

Fun Christmas drink!

Came here with our friends tonight and had a great time! Love the weird Paris noir vibe, catacombs, wax laden chandelier, and roof portraits , awesome! The drinks are curated based on your likes and sometimes that's hard to define if you are a person like myself that is up for anything. Whoever the male Bartender was tonight absolutely killed it! We regret not getting his name but boy oh boy were we all absolutely stoked about our drinks, he got all of them on the nose. My friend ordered a creamsicle and it was spot on... I ordered creamy fruity and got a wonderful raspberry drink, my husband likes spirit forward and tropical banana ish and got something called King Kong. And our other friend got a tiki drink... drinks are $18 a pop but worth it. Thank you! Will be back!

Speakeasy in a not so easy location. Should I reveal the secret doorway to this lavish experience... everyone has a price! I liked how I stumbled in and had one of the best handcrafted cocktails. I had to work some Sama magic to get in here being that I did not have a reservation. Nonetheless, I asked for something with tequila blanco and walaa... the tastiest drink you can put your lips on and give your tastebuds. It's very small in size and space, but impressive. I liked the feel, the look, and the mixologists. They know what they are doing here, because there is no menu. You ask for it and they will serve you something in that realm to WoW you. It was reasonably priced, under $20 per drink. You will not be disappointed by coming here, and even better, you'll impress your date as it has an intimate feel. FYI: It's best to make a reservation.

This place is a must to check out. A dope speakeasy! Love how the just ask what try of spirit and drink you're into and they will curate it for you. It reminds me of a spot when I visited Antigua, Guatamala where they did the same thing. No drink menu. It's a nice warm atmosphere and it gives very chill relaxed vibes. I highly recommend as the bartenders were very friendly and are attentive. Also if you look up at the ceiling you have some cool art work!

-Located in Neighborhood (look for the keg wall near the bathroom) -No menus: bartender asks for your preferences and it's their choice! -$18 per cocktail -Make a reservation because it's small Now that we've got the logistics out of the way, would highly recommend Noble Experiment. A great San Diego speakeasy mixing up delicious drinks. I love the concept and the bartenders were able to make me drinks that I absolutely loved despite my less than coherent likes and dislikes! The place is beautiful and I was shocked that the drinks were so reasonably priced for how nice it was.

See all photos from Courtney O. for Noble Experiment

A catacomb inspired speakeasy. Inside of the restaurant Neighborhood. Push the drum barrels near the restroom to get into Noble Experiment. There is no menu, the bartender asks you what you like and makes something based on what you tell them. I told bartender Zac that I loved Chi Chi's and Pina Coladas and he made me "Coughlin's Diet" which was amaro, rum, coconut, banana liqueur, and lime. It was light and refreshing. Highly recommend making a reservation, because it was packed on a Saturday night. I was a walk in and they had 1 spot at the bar, so I was lucky.

It was a long hard day yesterday, and thought a drink would cheer me up, so I came to Noble Experiment by myself. Had a 30 mins waitlist. Sierra was my bartender who left me feel completely unwanted there. She didn't want to hear what I want, left me with one drink and went to the other side of the bar and never came back. I am not sure Sierra why you hated my presence so much...Was it a bad day for you too or I am being only dark skin colored among the pool of white crowd made me an inferior customer? I would see you entertain other white customers gleefully and then look at my side as if I am invisible. You never came back to ask if I need another drink. I would look at you multiple time and you will see me but turn your head around. If I would have gotten the fraction of attention you are giving to those white ladies (who didn't even need anything), I would call it a win. The drink you made was good, but your treatment to me wasn't. Next time, may be treat a POC immigrant who gathered enough courage to go out by themselves after a shitty day little better with visibly less racial bias? Eventually I had to ask the other guy bartender to give me the check. Shoutout to that guy for being nice! No tips for you though!

It's interesting looking there's a lot of skulls on the wall, which makes it pretty cryptic looking. If you're into Gothic or medieval vibes, I said this is a good place to go to. It's small spaced, and more bar like setting. Very creative though from secret passage to the speakeasy entrance to the bar. It's very well executed. The guy was nice to us.

154 other reviews that are not currently recommended

Vogue Tavern

in Sports Bars, Cocktail Bars, Burgers

Bluewater Grill - Coronado

in Seafood, New American, Bars

Collections Including Noble Experiment

Best San Diego Restaurants & Bars

By Tyler F.

San Diego Must-eats From A Professional Eater

By Darcey H.

Restaurants + Bars In San Diego

By Adrianna B.

San Diego Top Quick Bites, Eateries And Dining Spots

By Charles N.

San Diego Speakeasies

By Courtney O.

San Diego • things to eat, see, and do

By Rachel T.

Gas Lamp, Little Italy, Coronado, Pacific beach And Balboa

San Diego - For Friends

San Diego Bar/Happy Hour

Visitors - San Diego

People Also Viewed

Young Blood

Polite Provisions

Raised By Wolves

Prohibition

Captain’s Quarters

Best of San Diego

Things to do in San Diego

People found Noble Experiment by searching for…

Bars And Lounges San Diego

Birthday Dinner San Diego

Birthday Ideas For Adults San Diego

Date Night San Diego

Fancy Restaurant San Diego

Fun Restaurants San Diego

Gaslamp District Bars San Diego

Gaslamp Speakeasy San Diego

Hip And Trendy Restaurants San Diego

Speak Easy San Diego

Speakeasy Bars San Diego

Tiki Bar San Diego

Browse Nearby

Restaurants

Things to Do

Other Cocktail Bars Nearby

Find more Cocktail Bars near Noble Experiment

• History Classics
• Your Profile
• Find History on Facebook (Opens in a new window)
• Find History on Twitter (Opens in a new window)
• Find History on YouTube (Opens in a new window)
• Find History on Instagram (Opens in a new window)
• Find History on TikTok (Opens in a new window)
• This Day In History
• History Podcasts
• History Vault

18th and 21st Amendments

By: History.com Editors

Updated: July 28, 2023 | Original: February 4, 2010

By the late 1800s, prohibition movements had sprung up across the United States, driven by religious groups who considered alcohol, specifically drunkenness, a threat to the nation. The movement reached its apex in 1919 with the ratification of the 18th Amendment, prohibiting the manufacture, transportation and sale of intoxicating liquors. Prohibition proved difficult to enforce and failed to have the intended effect of eliminating crime and other social problems–to the contrary, it led to a rise in organized crime, as the bootlegging of alcohol became an ever-more lucrative operation. In 1933, widespread public disillusionment led Congress to ratify the 21st Amendment, which repealed Prohibition.

Origins of Temperance Movement

A wave of intense religious revivalism that swept the U.S. during the 1820s and 30s led to the formation of a number of prohibition movements driven by religious groups who considered alcohol, specifically drunkenness, a “national curse.” (This revivalism also helped inspire the movement to end slavery.) The first temperance legislation appeared in 1838, in the form of a Massachusetts law prohibiting the sale of spirits in less than 15-gallon quantities. Though it was repealed two years later, Maine passed the first state prohibition law in 1846, and by the time the Civil War began, a number of other states had followed suit.

Did you know? Prohibition was known as "the noble experiment." The phrase was coined by President Herbert Hoover, who wrote to an Idaho senator in 1928: "Our country has deliberately undertaken a great social and economic experiment, noble in motive and far-reaching in purpose."

As early as 1873, the Women’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) of Ohio called for the abolition of the sale of alcohol. They were soon joined in the fight by the even more powerful Anti-Saloon League (ASL), founded in 1893 in Ohio but later expanded into a national organization that endorsed political candidates and lobbied for legislation against saloons. Beginning around 1906, the ASL led a renewed call for prohibition legislation at the state level. Through speeches, advertisements and public demonstrations at saloons and bars, prohibition advocates attempted to convince people that that eliminating alcohol from society would eliminate poverty and social vices, such as immoral behavior and physical violence. One prominent temperance advocate, Kentucky-born Carrie Amelia Moore Nation (she called herself “Carry A. Nation”), became known for particularly violent tactics against what she called “evil spirits.” In addition to making protest speeches, Nation was known for breaking saloon windows and mirrors and destroying kegs of beer or whiskey with a hatchet. She was arrested numerous times, and became a household name across the country for her “saloon-smashing” campaign.

From State to Federal Prohibition Legislation

By 1916, 23 of 48 states had passed anti-saloon legislation. Many went further, prohibiting the manufacture of alcoholic beverages as well. After the congressional elections that year, “dry” members (as those who favored a national prohibition of alcohol became known) won a two-thirds majority over “wet” in the U.S. Congress. On January 16, 1919, the requisite number of states ratified the 18th Amendment, which prohibited the manufacturing, transportation and sale of alcohol within the United States; it would go into effect the following January.

Later in 1919, the National Prohibition Act–popularly known as the Volstead Act, after its legislative sponsor, Representative Andrew J. Volstead of Minnesota–was enacted in order to provide the government with the means of enforcing Prohibition. Loopholes in this act–such as the fact that liquor used for medicinal, sacramental or industrial purposes remained legal, as did fruit or grape beverages prepared at home–as well as varying degrees of government support throughout the 1920s hampered the enforcement of Prohibition, and it would remain more of an ideal than a reality.

Unexpected Events

Under Prohibition, the illegal manufacture and sale of liquor–known as “bootlegging”–occurred on a large scale across the United States. In urban areas, where the majority of the population opposed Prohibition, enforcement was generally much weaker than in rural areas and smaller towns. Perhaps the most dramatic consequence of Prohibition was the effect it had on organized crime in the United States: as the production and sale of alcohol went further underground, it began to be controlled by the Mafia and other gangs, who transformed themselves into sophisticated criminal enterprises that reaped huge profits from the illicit liquor trade.

When it came to its booming bootleg business, the Mafia became skilled at bribing police and politicians to look the other way. Chicago’s Al Capone emerged as the most notorious example of this phenomenon, earning an estimated $60 million annually from the bootlegging and speakeasy operations he controlled. In addition to bootlegging, gambling and prostitution reached new heights during the 1920s as well. A growing number of Americans came to blame Prohibition for this widespread moral decay and disorder–despite the fact that the legislation had intended to do the opposite–and to condemn it as a dangerous infringement on the freedom of the individual.

Calls for Prohibition’s Repeal

If public sentiment had turned against Prohibition by the late 1920s, the advent of the Great Depression only hastened its demise, as some argued that the ban on alcohol denied jobs to the unemployed and much-needed revenue to the government. The efforts of the nonpartisan group Americans Against Prohibition Association (AAPA) added to public disillusionment. In 1932, the platform of Democratic presidential candidate Franklin D. Roosevelt included a plank for repealing the 18th Amendment, and his victory that November marked a certain end to Prohibition.

In February 1933, Congress adopted a resolution proposing the 21st Amendment to the Constitution , which repealed both the 18th Amendment and the Volstead Act. The resolution required state conventions, rather than the state legislatures, to approve the amendment, effectively reducing the process to a one-state, one-vote referendum rather than a popular vote contest. That December, Utah became the 36th state to ratify the amendment, achieving the necessary majority for repeal. A few states continued statewide prohibition after 1933, but by 1966 all of them had abandoned it. Since then, liquor control in the United States has largely been determined at the local level.

See All The Crafty Ways Americans Hid Alcohol During Prohibition

During the 13 dry years of Prohibition, sneaky Americans went to great lengths to conceal their alcohol consumption from law enforcement.

How America’s Iconic Brewers Survived Prohibition

The 13‑year ban on beer production during Prohibition forced America’s biggest brewers to find creative ways to remain in business.

Activist Carry Nation Used a Hatchet to Smash Booze Bottles Before Prohibition

Carry Nation had a bad history with alcohol—and she went to extremes to try and get it banned.

Sign up for Inside History

Get HISTORY’s most fascinating stories delivered to your inbox three times a week.

By submitting your information, you agree to receive emails from HISTORY and A+E Networks. You can opt out at any time. You must be 16 years or older and a resident of the United States.

More details : Privacy Notice | Terms of Use | Contact Us

• California RBS
• Connecticut
• GA Alcohol Delivery
• Illinois BASSET
• Massachusetts
• Mississippi
• New Hampshire
• North Carolina
• North Dakota
• Rhode Island
• Pennsylvania RAMP
• South Carolina
• South Dakota
• TN Beer Vendor Training
• West Virginia
• Washington DC
• Business Account
• Contact Us Support Help
• Food Handler Card
• Food Allergen Awareness
• Food Manager Certification
• Responsible Manager Course
• How To Make More Tips
• Behind the Bar Excellence
• Ultimate Guide To Bartending
• Knowledge Base
• Certificate Search
• Partner With Us
• Become An Affiliate
• Nightlife Security
• Responsible Hospitality
• Bartending License Guide
• Bartending 101
• Bartender Terms To Know
• Bartending Tools
• Bartending Tips
• Bartender Skills
• Bartending License Cost
• How Much Bartenders Make
• How Old To Be Bartender
• How to Become a Bartender
• Is Bartending School Worth It?
• Is Bartending A Good Job
• Drinks Bartenders Should Know
• Flair Bartending
• Bartender Statistics In US
• Bartending Class
• Mixology Class
• Best Bartender Guide Books
• Is Bartending School Worth It
• On The Job Training
• Free Bartender Cover Letter
• Job Search For Bartenders

Prohibition, Noble Experiment, and Volstead Act Explained

While the idea of not being able to drink alcohol is uncommon for most, there are still cities, counties, and states with strict, prohibition-esque drinking laws. In parts of  Arkansas , Georgia , Kansas , Kentucky , Mississippi , South Dakota , Tennessee , and Texas , for instance, there are “dry” counties or those that don’t sell alcohol. Technically speaking, Kansas, Mississippi, and Tennessee are considered “dry” states. Starting in 1920 and spanning 13 years, prohibition caused a temporary ban on alcohol.

Why did Prohibition Start?

Prohibition began on January 16, 1919, as a cultural movement of various Christian denominations and human rights organizations, with the help of political figures, trying to stop the sale and consumption of alcohol. This total ban came after a partial wartime ban was implemented on November 18, 1918, to save grain backstock. This decision was seen as a religious crusade as protestants, progressive Democrats and Republicans, the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, and the Anti-Saloon League joined together in hopes of promoting temperance (the act of not drinking). Only the Roman Catholics and German Lutherans rose to support keeping the alcohol industry going.

Noble Experiment

Prohibition became known as the “noble experiment.” It sought to remove the adverse side effects of drinking from society. The religious denominations against drinking said that allowing the sale of alcohol promoted alcoholism, domestic violence, corruption, and infidelity and generally went against public morals.

Volstead Act

As the movement gained momentum, it became a law (who remembers School House Rock’s video on how a bill becomes a law ?). It passed in “supermajority” through the House of Representatives and with the majority vote in the Senate in 1919. Around this time, the Volstead Act came into place. This act outlined the restrictions and exceptions allowed during prohibition. Spearheaded by the man who managed the legislation, Andrew Volstead, the legislation would extend and further restrict the wartime prohibition in place. As well as defined what was considered alcohol (0.5 percent or higher), enforcement, jail sentences, and seizures.

Speakeasy, Bootlegging, and Smugglers

In great American fashion, prohibition had almost the opposite effect on society. Those who wished to drink continued doing it; however, it was now illegal. Bootleggers and smugglers transported alcohol across the country. Speakeasies, illegal establishments selling alcohol, began popping up. Moonshine (an American homemade alcohol staple before and after prohibition) gained notoriety. It has been accredited for the spike in organized crime as mobs and gangs began forming in major cities and as the cause for a wave of people not showing up for work (absenteeism).

Repealing Prohibition

The public morals that pro-prohibition groups sought to improve only weakened. The weakened state of public morals caused a deterioration of support for prohibition after being in law for 13 years. In 1933, several bills were passed to lessen the restrictions on alcohol. The Cullen–Harrison Act increased the alcohol percentage by volume of beer and wine. The Blaine Act asked for the prohibition to be repealed. Most states accepted the repeal, with the final action coming on December 5, 1933, returning the alcohol sales and service industry to its former glory. Well, not really, but we’ll save that for another post.

Prohibition in the United States

World Atlas

Similar Posts

Characteristics of Under 21 Driver’s Licenses for All States

State Identifying Under 21 Driver’s License Elements Alaska License for minors is vertical with “UNDER...

Introducing Wisconsin Alcohol Seller-Server Training

From Madison to Milwaukee, we’ve got you covered! Our Wisconsin responsible beverage service course is...

Introducing Indiana Seller-Server Training

Signage: What you Need to Know

It doesn’t matter if your bar is old or new; there is one thing that...

5 Steps to Preventing Bartender Theft

Have you heard of the term shrinkage? Shrinkage refers to the liquor which is lost...

How Long Does a DUI Stay on Your Driving Record?

A DUI (driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol) is a serious misdemeanor that...

Dramshop Laws: Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, and Indiana

In this series, we’ll discuss what is dramshop and what you need to know about...

How Much is a Bartending License in Each State?

The cost of a bartending license varies depending on where you live, who your training...

Watch CBS News

Prohibition: America's failed "noble experiment"

June 12, 2012 / 9:38 PM EDT / CBS News

Prohibition was the so-called "noble experiment" which had some rather ignoble consequences ... as Mo Rocca will remind us:

The nightclub ... the speedboat ... the mob ... men and women drinking together ... the spread of jazz ... the booze cruise ... the powder room ... the cocktail.

What do they all have in common? They're the results - direct and indirect - of Prohibition, the nearly 14-year period from 1920 to 1933 when the manufacture, sale or transportation of "intoxicating liquor" was illegal in this country.

The nightclub - the "speakeasies" of the time of Prohibition - led to the nightclubs of modern times. The speedboat made its debut during Prohibition; it was the transport mode of choice for crime groups smuggling liquor into the United States across the Great Lakes and other bodies of water.

"Booze cruises" would take passengers beyond American territorial waters - and out of the reach of the law - so that patrons could enjoy alcoholic beverages.

Before the era of Prohibition (which took effect about the time the 19th Amendment gave women the right to vote in 1920), saloons were largely a "men only" affair. Speakeasies, on the other hand, were frequented by men and women alike. Jazz was often provided as entertainment at these clubs, dancing was common, and - as more and more women frequented these establishments - powder rooms became de rigueur.

Since much of the illegal liquor sold in the United State during the time of Prohibition was less than top quality, mixed drinks... cocktails ... grew in popularity, allowing bartenders to mask the taste of poor quality booze with juices and other beverages.

"Why do you love the story so much?" Rocca asked Daniel Okrent, author of "Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition."\

"It's the answer to that question, how the hell did that happen?" he replied. "I mean, it's just so improbable. How did this freedom-loving country put into the organic law, into the Constitution , this unbelievable stricture that said that you can't have a glass of beer? It's really hard to believe."

Part of the reason was simply that Americans liked to drink ... a lot.

"This country was very, very drunk," Okrent said. "In 1830 the average American over 15 years of age drank 7.3 gallons of pure alcohol a year. That's the equivalent of 90 fifths of 80-proof liquor, 1.8 bottles per week for every drinker in the country."

"We shouldn't forget that alcoholism is a serious social problem. It was a social problem in the 19th century which prompted Prohibition, it is today" said filmmaker Ken Burns.

Burns and producer Lynn Novick have collaborated on documentaries about jazz and baseball. In their newest film, airing tonight on PBS, they take on Prohibition.

Prohibition was billed, they point out, as the "one-size-fits-all" cure for the ills of American society.

"Prohibition was really sold as not just that it would solve the problem of alcoholism, it would solve poverty. It would solve child labor, it would solve prostitution, it would solve crime, it would get rid of slums," said Novick.

With so many problems to address, it's not surprising that the Dry coalition was dizzyingly diverse.

Suffragettes who originally wanted the vote so they could outlaw demon liquor ... small town Protestants threatened by the wave of Catholic immigrants and their city saloons ... the Ku Klux Klan, who exploited the pernicious stereotype of the dangerous black man with a bottle ... even Broadway producers who wanted patrons out of bars (and in their theaters).

It was, Rocca noted, the epitome of strange bedfellows.

Okrent agreed: "If you can imagine a very large bed that accommodates, you know, some guy wearing a KKK uniform, somebody from the Industrial Workers of the World, Jane Addams, and J.J. Shubert of the theater chain, that's a very strange set of bedfellows."

"Is it true that the KKK supported women's suffrage?" asked Rocca.

"The KKK supported it because they knew that women would support Prohibition," Okrent said.

"Geez! That's the story of Prohibition. It's all, 'Geez!'" Okrent laughed. "Who knew?"

But who could possibly wrangle this crazy quilt coalition?

"I think it's clear that ASL was the most powerful lobbying group pressure group," Okrent said. "They actually made a constitutional amendment happen."

The ASL - or Anti-Saloon League.

Okrent said that what made them effective was, "They said to you, 'I don't care what you think about whether babies ought to be slaughtered or whether we should start wars. We don't care about any of those things at all. You're with us on our one issue.

"They were not party-affiliated. And they in fact had very strong influence in both parties by design. The organization that's most like them today is the NRA. One issue, that's all we care about.

And the League's seat of power? Not New York ... not Washington ... but Westerville, Ohio.

At its headquarters, the League employed 200 people in a state-of-the-art printing operation that generated 40 tons of propaganda a month. Madison Avenue, take note.

Nina Thomas, an archivist at the town's Anti-Saloon League Museum, displayed a poster that said, "'The saloon, or the boys and the girls?' - just that emotion of, 'Would you rather have a saloon or would you rather have your children?'"

Or, "Shall the mothers and children be sacrificed to the financial greed of the liquor trade? It's up to you to decide."

The message was clear ... even if the facts sometimes weren't.

One ASL poster read, "Do you know one insane person in every four owes his insanity to drink?"

Pivotal to Prohibition's passage: Anti-German sentiment fomented by World War I.

Pabst ... Schlitz ... Anheuser-Busch ... all of them German.

"They linked the Germans to the brewers," Thomas said. "People had it in the back of their heads that it was un-American."

Though the brewers and distillers had vast financial resources, they were inept campaigners.

An ad extolling the virtues of beer shows a baby with a beer stein.

"Yeah, the brewers wanted to separate themselves from the distillers," explained Okrent. "They maintained that gin and whiskey - that was horrible, poisonous stuff - whereas our beer was healthy. They actually called it liquid bread."

The Drys had the Wets over a barrel, and the 18th Amendment went into effect at midnight on January 17, 1920.

And how soon did it become clear that it was not going to work?

"One could say it didn't work by around 2:00 a.m. on January 17th," Okrent laughed. "I think that the general feeling was in the first year that it could work and that it was working. But as people found ways to exploit the loopholes, and criminality expanded, as the saloons were able to turn themselves into speakeasies and all you needed to do was bribe a local cop or judge, these things began to snowball as early as 1921, 1922."

Legitimate enterprises were corrupted and respect for the law corroded. Drug stores - allowed to dispense medicinal alcohol - became virtual liquor stores.

The Walgreen's chain went from 20 to 525.

But the ultimate buzzkill?

"It really is the Depression,' said Novick, "this incredible crisis that, I think, made America kind of take another look and say, 'Wait, what are our priorities? Is this really that important? We're spending all this money to enforce a law that nobody wants?'"

Drinking did decline 70 percent from pre-Prohibition levels in the first few years. But the Drys were up against something even more powerful than money:

"What you can't successfully legislate against is human appetite," said Okrent. "If people want something, they're going to find a way to get it."

On December 5th, 1933, the 21st Amendment passed, ending Prohibition - the only time in history an amendment has been repealed. The noble experiment was over.

"It was a failure by any measurement, but positive in its failure," said Okrent. "We learn from our failures. We learn, 'Let's not try this again.'"

       For more info:

• "Prohibition" (PBS)
• "Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition" by Daniel Okrent (Scribner)
• danielokrent.com
• Anti-Saloon League Museum at the Westerville Public Library, Westerville, Ohio

More from CBS News

Secretary of State Antony Blinken on America's role in the world

Book excerpt: "Brooke Shields is Not Allowed to Get Old"

Jamie Dimon on the economy, billionaires, and income inequality

When to view the first full moon of 2025, January's Wolf Moon

• Todays Fact
• U.S. History
• World History
• Famous Figures
• Arts & Culture
• Science & Industry

The U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition.

• Share to email
• Share to Facebook
• Bootleg liquor circa 1930s

It’s been dubbed the “noble experiment,” a name that came from then-President Herbert Hoover calling Prohibition “a great social and economic experiment, noble in motive and far-reaching in purpose.” In January 1920, the United States banned the manufacture, sale, and transportation of “intoxicating liquors,” a move made in the wake of temperance movements that sought moral and social reform throughout the 1800s — in spite of some failed attempts at similar regional programs around the country. 

You may also like

By the Numbers

Modern equivalent of how much Al Capone made each year during Prohibition

$1.7 billion

Year statewide Prohibition finally ended in Mississippi

Number of rum-only distilleries in NYC (named, winkingly, the Noble Experiment)

Average number of daily alcohol deliveries made by Congress’ own Prohibition-era bootlegger

Did you know?

Organized crime started because of prohibition..

Before Prohibition, organized crime was mostly limited to small gangs who were involved in petty neighborhood extortion and loan-sharking . When the 1920 ban on alcohol went into effect, mobsters became the key players in the illicit alcohol trade, procuring, producing, and selling liquor illegally all over the U.S. Profits got so big, so fast, that these once small-time criminals and mafias learned to be more “organized” than ever, hiring lawyers , accountants, truckers, and more to help run their illicit businesses. They also started working with other criminal groups, effectively creating underground syndicates . Powerful crime families led by figures such as Charles “Lucky” Luciano and the notorious Al Capone emerged, making millions of dollars in the process . The enormous profits fueled the growth and expansion of organized crime, which continued even after the repeal of Prohibition.

More on Politics

• Fascinating Facts About Every First Lady
• Who Wrote the Constitution?
• The Bizarre Election of George Washington

Author Nicole Villeneuve

Love it? 12

What Was the War of 1812?

Love it? 190

Recommendations For You

6 Facts About the Mount Rushmore Presidents

7 Little-Known Facts About America’s Founding Fathers

13 Facts About the 13 Original Colonies 

5 Watergate Facts You Probably Didn’t Know

Subscribe to history facts.

Enter your email to receive history's most fascinating happenings in your inbox each day.

Your email is:

By clicking “Subscribe” you agree to History Fact’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy .

Noble Experiments? A Primer on Prohibition and Public Health

Source:  Rare Historical Photos : The night Prohibition ended, Dec. 5, 1933

Last Thursday marked the 86th anniversary of the repeal of Prohibition, ending what many called a 13-year “noble experiment” to ban alcohol consumption nationwide. Even though it was well intentioned – to improve health and decrease poverty, crime and corruption – it was ultimately deemed a failure. Why?

Liquor consumption did initially decline dramatically – as much as 70% -- with an accompanying decrease in cirrhosis. But according to a Boston University study , prohibitions generally become lucrative opportunities for black market suppliers, resulting in rising demand through a “forbidden fruit” effect, and increasing both violent and nonviolent crime. Another outcome is decreased quality control, causing overdoses and accidental poisonings.

Across-the-board bans may feel emotionally satisfying, but they ignore the scientific evidence. This may be significant in the current debate over restricting or banning all vaping of electronic cigarettes across the board. To that end, a new paper was published today in Science , to which we are both contributing authors.

It warns against prohibitionist measures doing more harm than good if they conflate three completely different issues: the vaping of nicotine that helps save smokers from deadly cigarettes; the rise in teen vaping; and the sudden rash of tragic deaths and lung illness from vaping illicit cannabis (the vaping of illicit cannabis THC oils is a very different challenge that must be addressed separately).

Each and every day  1,200 Americans die -- one every 1-2 minutes -- due to smoking cigarettes. So the authors argue that “combustible products should be much more aggressively and stringently regulated than non-combusted nicotine products.” The nicotine or flavors in legally purchased nicotine vape products from known makers and vape shops have been used by millions of smokers for almost 10 years.

Teen vaping of nicotine must also be regulated as we do with alcohol (e.g., age restrictions) to minimize harm and unintended consequences. But while policy makers at the federal and state levels are now rushing to consider blanket vaping bans or just banning nicotine and flavors, none are proposing similar bans on deadly combusted cigarettes and little cigars that come in many flavors -- despite the remarkable deaths reported from smoking and not from nicotine itself. Vaping nicotine could displace smoking, so banning vaping helps keep combusteds on the market.

Scientific evidence can help thread this needle to maximize benefits and minimize harms. The authors suggest using science, not knee-jerk emotion, to guide public health policy and regulation.

Prohibition didn’t work for alcohol, and it would fail for nicotine vape products for the same reasons. Instead, effective regulation is the answer to protecting public health.

Cheryl Healton, DrPH GPH Dean and Professor of Public Health Policy and Management

David B. Abrams, PhD Professor of Social and Behavioral Sciences

Posted on: November 18, 2022

The Noble Experiment: Why Prohibition and the Volstead Act Failed

American president Herbert Hoover referred to Prohibition as "a great social and economic experiment, noble in motive and far-reaching in purpose." The term "noble" relates to the objective of keeping families together and reducing or eliminating alcohol abuse. Many individuals seemed to agree with this opinion, and eventually, people referred to Prohibition as the “noble experiment.” 

Prohibition, or the “noble experiment,” was a nationwide ban that prohibited the manufacture, transportation, and sale of alcohol. It was enacted in the United States in January 1920 and lasted 13 years. 

Prohibition would go on to ultimately fail for various reasons. Before its repeal in 1933, Prohibition significantly impacted American society. But what caused Prohibition and the Volstead Act to fail? 

When Was Alcohol Illegal? 

Nationwide Prohibition lasted 13 years, from 1920 until 1933. The U.S. Congress passed the 18th Amendment in 1917. In 1919 the amendment was ratified by three-quarters of the nation's states required to make it constitutional.

What Caused Prohibition? 

Prohibition was the attempt to prohibit the production and consumption of alcohol in the United States. The push for Prohibition started mainly as a religious movement in the early 19th century – the first state Prohibition law was approved in Maine in 1846, and the Prohibition Party was founded in 1869. 

Social reformers who believed alcohol to be the source of poverty, industrial accidents, and tearing apart families helped the movement gather momentum in the 1880s and 1890s. Other supporters linked alcohol to urban immigrant ghettos, criminality, and political corruption.

Later, the war provided a huge boost for the temperance movement. With America’s entry into the First World War in 1917, President Woodrow Wilson put in place a temporary wartime Prohibition to conserve grain for producing food. This decision was also targeted toward brewers, most of who came of German descent. 

The 18th Amendment, which outlawed the manufacture, transportation, and sale of intoxicating liquors, was put forth for state ratification by Congress that same year. Despite a seven-year time limit set by Congress, the amendment was approved by the required three-quarters of U.S. states in only 11 months.

The 18th Amendment was ratified on January 16, 1919, and it became effective one year later, when no less than 33 states had already passed their Prohibition laws.

In October 1919, Congress instituted the National Prohibition Act, which established regulations for the federal enforcement of Prohibition. Championed by Representative Andrew Volstead of Minnesota, the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, the measure was more popularly known as the Volstead Act.

Why Did Prohibition Start? 

There was a wide range of economic, political, and social reasons for Prohibition.

According to Cato Institute , the National prohibition of liquor was implemented to reduce crime and corruption, solve social issues, reduce the tax burden created by prisons and poorhouses, and improve health and hygiene in America.

However, the “noble experiment” results evidently demonstrate that it was a complete failure all around. 

Why Did Prohibition Fail? 

There were various unintended consequences of Prohibition. First, Prohibition's impacts on the economy were generally negative because of the thousands of jobs that were lost because of the closure of brewers, distilleries, and saloons.

Moreover, one of prohibition's most significant unintended consequences was on government tax revenues. Before Prohibition, several states greatly depended on excise taxes on the sale of alcohol for funding. At the national level, Prohibition cost the federal government a total of $11 billion in lost tax revenue while spending approximately $300 million to enforce it. 

So, why did prohibition fail miserably? The Volstead Act enforced the 18th amendment's requirements and had a severe defect at its core. It banned the manufacture, sale, and distribution of alcohol for drinking purposes, but it did not outlaw consumption, meaning people could still drink alcohol if they had access to it. 

From those who produced and sold alcohol illegally, or "bootlegged," which grew rapidly and placed money directly into the pockets of "bootleggers", to those who made "moonshine" at home, which could sometimes be fatal when consumed, and to the "speakeasies," or illegal drinking establishments, that emerged throughout urban America, having access to alcohol was not a challenge. 

Presidents, senators, congressmen, and police chiefs drank alcohol. Therefore, fortunes based on "bootlegging" were generated by disregarding criminals like Al Capone. 

Clearly, organized crime and political corruption increased, and liquor prohibition created a difficult life for most drinkers. During Prohibition, the goal of turning away from spirits and toward beer was reversed because “bootleggers” could generate more money by smuggling spirits.

Prohibition ultimately failed because:  

• At least 50% of the adult population wanted to continue drinking 
• Policing of the Volstead Act was filled with contradictions, biases, and corruption
• There was a lack of detail for the ban on consumption, leading to confusion about the law

The law that was intended to promote temperance for over a decade instead promoted excess and intemperance. The strategy the United States came up with to deal with the issue of alcohol abuse actually made it worse. 

Why Was Prohibition so Difficult to Enforce? 

Enforcing Prohibition proved to be incredibly challenging. Throughout the 1920s, both federal and local governments struggled to enforce Hoover’s “noble experiment.” 

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) was initially assigned to enforce Prohibition; this responsibility was ultimately passed over to the Justice Department and the Bureau of Prohibition.

By the end of the 1920s, public support for Prohibition was diminishing due to the increase in "bootlegging," the expansion of speakeasies, and the increase in gang and organized crime.

Since the national government lacked the resources and motivation to attempt to police every border, lake, river, and speakeasy in America, bootlegging grew prevalent. In fact, there were somewhere between 30,000 and 100,000 speakeasies in New York City alone by 1925. 

The law that was designed to prevent Americans from drinking liquor instead made many of them experts in producing it. 

Public health suffered significantly because of the unregulated alcohol trade. The quality of alcohol on the black market decreased as the illegal alcohol trade grew more profitable. During Prohibition, contaminated alcohol caused 1,000 American deaths annually on average.

The Prohibition era changed everything. Although consumption rates eventually reached pre-1920 rates, alcohol was never again seen or consumed the same way.

Instead, now we require those who serve alcohol, such as bartenders, to take regulated alcohol training . Enroll today!

Get Alcohol Training in Your State

• Connecticut
• District of Columbia
• Massachusetts
• Mississippi
• New Hampshire
• North Carolina
• North Dakota
• Pennsylvania
• Rhode Island
• South Carolina
• South Dakota
• West Virginia