Naval Postgraduate School
Where Science Meets the Art of Warfare
NPS Student, Professor Win 2021 USNI Information Warfare Essay Contest
MC2 Tom Tonthat | February 15, 2022
Computer Science doctoral student U.S. Navy Cmdr. Edgar Jatho, left, and his advisor Assistant Professor Joshua A. Kroll are the winners of the U.S. Naval Institute 2021 Information Warfare Essay Contest with their award-winning piece, “Artificial Intelligence: Too Fragile to Fight?”
U.S. Navy Cmdr. Edgar Jatho, a doctoral student in the Naval Postgraduate School (NPS) Department of Computer Science, and his advisor Assistant Professor Joshua A. Kroll have been named the winners of the U.S. Naval Institute (USNI) 2021 Information Warfare Essay Contest for their piece, “ Artificial Intelligence: Too Fragile to Fight? ”
Jatho and Kroll will be honored this week at an awards ceremony during WEST 2022, a large naval conference and exposition in San Diego, Feb. 16-18. In addition, their award-winning essay has been published in the February issue of USNI’s Proceedings .
The essay cautions on the overreliance of AI and raises awareness of potential issues and exploits that can affect its effectiveness in the field. Jatho got the inspiration to write about the essay for the annual USNI contest while taking Kroll’s Trustworthy and Responsible AI course in 2020.
“The course involved reading leading thinkers across disciplines about AI, automation and algorithms,” said Jatho. “It brought up the challenges and difficulties in implementing safe and ethical systems that leverage the technology … Now that we have this big impetus by the DOD to adopt artificial intelligence and machine learning into technology on all kinds of different levels and solutions, it’s easy for us to forget some hard-won lessons.”
In addition to his NPS coursework, Jatho was inspired by one of the presenters in NPS’ longstanding Secretary of the Navy Guest Lecture (SGL) series. During his October 2021 lecture on future of warfare, retired U.S. Navy Adm. James Stavridis cautioned how the military’s overreliance on advanced technology can leave it vulnerable to massive disruption.
“Dependence on a new technology like cyberspace, artificial intelligence or nanotechnology will enable you to move forward,” said Stavridis during the SGL. “But does it create an Achilles’ heel? Often it does.”
“Based on all of the research that I’ve been reading of what’s possible, it really got me to think,” continued Jatho. “[AI] can be a very complex and difficult problem because you can find support that says it’s doing a great job. Then suddenly when it gets to the battlefield, you find that it’s extraordinarily brittle and easy to break.”
Jatho credits the many resources at NPS supporting his education and research, and the opportunities to apply his studies, for his winning piece. Leading among them is Kroll, Jatho’s advisor and co-author of the essay.
“I’m quite proud that we in NPS can be in this position of thought leadership for the Navy and we can do the work to really think strategically,” said Kroll. “That’s something that I don’t think comes as naturally from other institutions that aren’t as focused on defense-oriented problems.”
As the winning essay, the USNI presents Jatho and Kroll’s cautions about AI as part of its mission to advance the professional, literary and scientific understanding of sea power and other issues critical to global security.
It is critical for NPS faculty and students to contribute their work to these kinds of leading venues, Kroll says, that collect and distribute these ideas to the naval and defense community.
“They’re a trusted voice in this DOD community,” he says, “and I hope we can have an impact with how people can make our naval capabilities support the execution of the mission in a more robust and trustworthy way.”
Jatho continues the pursuit of a Ph.D. in Computer Science at NPS, and is slated to teach at the Naval Academy following graduation as part of the Permanent Military Professor program.
MEDIA CONTACT
Office of University Communications 1 University Circle Monterey, CA 93943 (831) 656-1068 https://nps.edu/office-of-university-communications [email protected]
U.S. Indo-Pacific Command Charts a Course for Countering China’s Legal Warfare
Submission Guidelines
- Open to all contributors -- active-duty, military, reservists, veterans, and civilians.
- Essays must be no more than 2,500 words , excluding end notes and sources. Include word count on title page of the essay.
- Essays are judged in the blind. Do not include your name on the title page or in the body of the essay.
- Submit essay as a Word document at www.usni.org/iwessay no later than 30 November 2020.
- Essay must be original and not previously published (online or in print) or being considered for publication elsewhere.
First Prize: $5,000
Second Prize: $2,500
Third Prize: $1,500
Selection Process
The Proceedings staff members will evaluate every essay and screen the top essays to a special Essay Selection Committee of at least six members who will include two members of the Naval Institute’s Editorial Board and four subject experts.
Announcement of the Winners
The winning essays will be published in Proceedings magazine and on the Naval Institute website. The winners will be recognized during the Naval Institute–AFCEA WEST 2021 Conference.
Selected Submissions
Previous Winners
2022 information warfare essay contest sponsored by booz allen hamilton, 2021 information warfare essay contest sponsored by booz allen hamilton, receive the newsletter.
Sign up to get updates about new releases and event invitations.
IMAGES
COMMENTS
2022 Information Warfare Essay Contest. Sponsored by Booz Allen Hamilton. Deadline. 30 November 2022. The Nation's adversaries and competitors are proving to be formidable in the digital battlespace. Essay Contest.
What role will electronic warfare and emissions control play in the future of naval warfare? Submission Guidelines. Open to all contributors -- active-duty military, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Essays must be no more than 2,500 words, excluding end notes and sources. Include word count on title page of the essay. Essays are judged in ...
MONTEREY, Calif. - U.S. Navy Cmdr. Edgar Jatho, a doctoral student in the Naval Postgraduate School (NPS) Department of Computer Science, and his advisor Assistant Professor Joshua A. Kroll have been
MONTEREY, Calif. - U.S. Navy Cmdr. Edgar Jatho, a doctoral student in the Naval Postgraduate School (NPS) Department of Computer Science, and his advisor Assistant Professor Joshua A. Kroll have been named the winners of the U.S. Naval Institute (USNI) 2021 Information Warfare Essay Contest for their piece, "Artificial Intelligence: Too ...
Naval Institute website. The first-prize winner will appear in the February 2021 ... INFORMATION WARFARE ESSAY CONTEST SPONSORED BY THE REWARD First Prize: $5,000 Second Prize: $2,500 Third Prize: $1,500 All winners will receive a 1-year membership in the Naval Institute. SUBMISSION GUIDELINES Open to all contributors— active-duty military ...
Submissions for USNI's Information Warfare Essay Contest are due by 30 November!
Information Warfare Essay Contest—Third Prize, Sponsored by Booz Allen Hamilton. Information warfare will play a role in the next conflict, and the Navy needs more secure systems.
meager resources and institutional resistance. This year's Naval Intelligence Essay Contest challenges you to think about the roles of naval intelligence in this dynamic and uncertain future. Potential themes include: • How can naval intelligence most effectively sense, understand, and
Almost from the earliest days of the Naval Institute, its essay contests have been one of its most important functions. On 13 June 1878, with Commander Alfred Thayer Mahan as acting Chair, the Naval Institute adopted rules for the first essay contest — the General Prize Essay Contest. This contest continues to this day.
Information Warfare Essay Contest—First Prize, Sponsored by Booz Allen Hamilton. The community needs a cadre of officers who can define requirements for new capabilities. 08 Jun 2023 23:01:30
U.S. Navy Cmdr. Edgar Jatho, a doctoral student in the Naval Postgraduate School (NPS) Department of Computer Science, and his advisor Assistant Professor Joshua A. Kroll have been named the winners of the U.S. Naval Institute (USNI) 2021 Information Warfare Essay Contest for their piece, " Artificial Intelligence: Too Fragile to Fight? Jatho ...
The U.S. Naval Institute Information Warfare Essay Contest contest is open to all contributors -- active-duty military, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Essays must be no more than 2,500 words, excluding end notes and sources. Include word count on title page of the essay. Essays are judged in the blind.
ANNAPOLIS, MD. (Sept. 21, 2023) Rear Adm. Fred Kacher, acting Superintendent for the Naval Academy; Naval History and Heritage Command Director, retired Rear. Adm. Sam Cox, and Chief Executive Officer of the U.S. Naval Institute, retired Vice Adm. Peter H. Daly present awards to Lt. Vince Kindfuller for his third prize essay in the Rising Historian Category titled, "Rekindling Innovation in ...
How will electronic warfare and emissions control play a role in the future of naval warfare? Submission Guidelines. Open to all contributors -- active-duty military, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Essays must be no more than 2,500 words, excluding end notes and sources. Include word count on title page of the essay. Essays are judged in ...
ARLINGTON, Va.—The results are in for the recent Naval Horizons student essay contest—organized by the Department of the Navy's (DoN) Naval STEM Coordination Office, which is located at the Office of Naval Research (ONR).
The U.S. Naval Institute Information Warfare Essay Contest is an annual writing competition sponsored by the U.S. Naval Institute to encourage original
competition, naval forces are tied to every aspect of deterrence— and to operations should deterrence fail. Faced with this deteriorating environment, this year's Naval Intelligence Essay Contest challenges you to think about how naval intelligence supports naval power across the Sea Services. Potential themes include:
"I highly encourage all Coast Guard personnel who sense changes within this field to articulate the opportunities through this essay contest." The essay contest is open to all: active-duty, military, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Resources. ALCOAST 021/21; For more information on the contest, and specific instructions on how to ...
The U.S. Naval Institute Future of Naval Warfare Essay Contest is available to active-duty military members, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Selection is based on a 3,000-word maximum essay discussing recommendations for the innovations required to shape the future capabilities of the Sea Services.
A panel of expert judges compiled by the U.S. Naval Institute and Naval Intelligence Professionals will evaluate and judge all entries submitted to the contest. Essays will be judged in the blind—i.e., the judging panel will not know the authors of the essays.
The threat of violence looms large behind China's campaign of "legal warfare" and Congress is taking note. Section 1284 of the Senate's draft Fiscal Year 2025 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) directs the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) to submit a report on "hostile legal operations," a term synonymous with legal warfare.
The Future of Naval Warfare Essay Contest. Deadline. 31 March 2024. The December 2023 Proceedings outlines a scenario for a hypothetical war in the western Pacific that begins in 2026. Quicklinks. About the Naval Institute. Books & Press. Naval History. USNI News.
How will electronic warfare and emissions control play a role in the future of naval warfare? Submission Guidelines. Open to all contributors -- active-duty, military, reservists, veterans, and civilians. Essays must be no more than 2,500 words, excluding end notes and sources. Include word count on title page of the essay. Essays are judged in ...